昨天看到这则《我报》英文新闻就啧啧称奇。
大概就是说,一位新加坡英文老师在批改了三年级学生作文后发表了四篇他认为“比他九岁时写的还差”的作文,与大家分享。然后就被众矢之,说他那么做并没有在课业上帮到他们,反而是在打击那几位学生,布拉布拉布拉~
引发了我的深思。。。
部落格虽为抒发想法;或与人分享看法的平台,但如果牵涉到自己职业范围内(政客除外)的课题还是得小心点。须知若要人不知;除非己莫写 – 在这种虚拟大千世界,只要你把东西放上网,就应该做好准备让全互联网的人都看得到了咯(除非你有什么特定安全防备,但世事无绝对)。站在那些学生的立场,老师既然没有帮助我们改进自己的英文也罢,竟然还在揶揄我们的英文差。。。不要说学生本身,家长一看就更不得了。况且这种事情还是发生在“投诉文化”盛行的新加坡,可怜的老师就被革职了。
曾经看过一个关于商业机密的短片,就是某公司高层为了测试自己员工对机密资讯的保护性有多高而聘请了一位专业收集资料人士进来公司。那位人士只拥有最普通的通行证来进出普通公司范围,但却要在一个星期内竭尽所能挖到越多机密越好。结果是,他从打印机上没人认领的文件、假冒同事电话、没人管理的电脑、传真机获取很多内幕消息去禀告那位雇佣他的人。是有点夸张,不过重要的就是咱们要敬业,重要的资料要收好,要负责。然后,只字不在其他平台发表任何关于自己行业的消息等~当然,也包括在自己的部落格上。。。
除了认识我真人的朋友知道我是做哪一行的,其他读者应该也不知道吧?不过不重要啦。。。喜欢读我写的东西就好,不是吗?
哦,附上那个好像已被拿下来的部落格所写的那一个英文帖子:
Tuesday, January 29, 2008
i have just finished marking 36 compositions written by my primary 3 class. sheesh. headache man. i need to study but oh man i have all these work to do. well… even though i had a headache marking all that nonsesne compositions, i have to say i do have a handful of good ones. a HANDFUL only. i seriously don’t remember my standard of english to be so horrible back when i was 9. Lucas i am sure u agree with me after i have shared with you some of the horrible language i got. haha.
well, i have 3 terribly ridiculous compositions that i shall post on this very blog of mine. a source of entertainment i should say. and i will type it out in its purest form. no corrections or whatsoever. WORD FOR WORD, mistake for mistake, paragraph for paragraph (or rather no paragraphing at all)… … ENJOY!!! xP
Compo 1:
At Sunday afternoon, their building was burn. They dashed outside, they can’t fine their child and they are very sad. Their parent called the fire engine to come. The fire engine came, the fire engine dashed inside to rescue the child, the fire engine is as brave as a lion, they went inside and the door is lock, he bank the door and its open sudderly he bank until the child and the child is inpain. They rescue the boy. Their parents is very glad that they rescue their child. They saw the fire engine taking him out of the building. They were very thankful to the fire engine.
Compo 2:
One morning there was a fire in a building. And everybody were screaming and shouting and running away. And crying.
And Tom mother was worried because Tom was trapped inside. They were crying.
But soon now later they find Tom were very happy that is not injured. Tom missed them and they missed Tom. And they wept of there tears they were gald that Tom is not injured.
And were very happy. And they Tom this will not happen again. and they live happily ever after. And were so the firefrighthers save the child And they so happy. every after.
Compo 3:
One day there was a boy in the house. All the people was crying. The boy mother and father tell the fireman about the boy at the house inside have had fire. The fireman did their best. The fireman use the water to make the inside the house. They use their helmet to bang the door. Because there was fire. The fire safe the boy. The boy was safe. The boy can’t go out because all the fire was trapped by him. Her mother was very happy to see him come back. The fire was very big. The boy was crying inside the house. The fire man tell the boy to come out.
Well, since i am at it… why not one last one. hahaha!
Compo 4:
One sunday a building has fire everyone, Run away and one women was finding her son, The womon talk to the men she said save my son, my son is the building at 9 floor then the men go to 9 floor then he looking for the boy, then he save the boy and the mother and father are very very very happy the boy mother and father very very Thank you to the men, Then whole frily were very very very happy and to thier very very old house and they live with thire Grandma and the boy mother told his Grandma said the men is a brave men.
Alright… 4 compos… and i assure you that i DID NOT CHANGE ANYTHING OR ADD IN ANYTHING. =.= boy oh boy… now i know why i can get a headache and laugh at the same time. ohwell… that would be all…
and… HAPPY BIRTHDAY SARA! now that you are 19… you are older… but wiser too! =)
# posted by Jonathan : 8:49 PM
看了,见人见智。不过我好像从电邮受过很多写得更夸张的小朋友的作品。。。
13 Responses
鈧凯
20|Feb|2008 1嗯,很多人也是对我的工作感好奇,我直接回答:我是二世祖。
小芳
21|Feb|2008 2谢谢你的提醒。我把东西写上部落,就预了给全世界的人看到,我知道自己要让别人知道的尺度在那里。
不过我觉得,我应该还不至于暴露公司机密吧,只是有点微言,同事都有在看,高层就应该不会看到吧。
夏娃
21|Feb|2008 3鈧凯
我都回答量地的
XD~~~
HARRIET
21|Feb|2008 4其实这老师也只是个小朋友.十几岁.
我比较想说的是,有点太大惊小怪了.
不至于到打击吧.
当然,写了就得负责,没错.
只是,事情真的那么严重咩.
chengsun
21|Feb|2008 5harriet,
个人觉得, 不小了, 在等进大学, 男生的话也有 21 了.
这样取笑自己教导的学生, 不应该.
思斌
22|Feb|2008 6有时候碰到此类事还真的是见人见智。但平心而论,我若是那位学生也会不高兴咯。。。可能也因此变成朋友的笑柄。所以那位老师还是得小心点。。。博客老师们也小心点啊~
HARRIET
22|Feb|2008 7我其实想说的不是那位老师没有错。他有错。是当然的。而且更衰的是他写在BLOG里面。
只是,我觉得,报导得那么严重,真得必要吗?
我听说是十九岁。十九岁时,我们不做错吗?(换言之,这男生不是也还是个等待进大学的学生?)
他写的时候大概就只是想:WALAU,我改的作文真的是有够头痛。所以就写出来了。(而且写的当时,我们也不知道学生的态度是否顽劣?后面还有没有一些其他的元素。)
只是站在不同的立场而已。
而小朋友们不高兴是当然的咯。我当然不赞同老师批评功课不好的同学。小斌同学。
当我觉得学生写了一些东西很好笑的时候,我也会笑。那叫取笑吗?
而且写BLOG的大家都知道,有时我们写的时候是无意识的。
真的是立场不同。
我是老师。我希望育人。但是有时候社会无形的枷锁压在身上时,我真的无言。
(我不知道我要怎么告诉大家我的感觉,我只是觉得,不要把老师当圣人。我们也在学习啊。就像你取笑同事的话应该不会上报吧?)
WALAU,有够长。
哈。(老师压力太大了,难怪时时刻刻我都有转行的念头。)
不过,大家,不要在意。观点不同。而已。
chengsun
22|Feb|2008 8当然可以笑, 但是心态和语气很重要. 他的文章里的语气给我的感觉很糟, 比较类似于戏虐. 如果他写类似 “see, their composition so cute. can see that they are not so strong in english, must think of some ways to help them improve”, 然后是学生的作文, 我想反弹不会那么大. 只能说他的 EQ 差, lesson learnt, move on.
当然, 因为这里小, 所以就会变很大事.
HARRIET
22|Feb|2008 9是的。可能语气很差。
而我,也许把他当小孩。
我的反应,或许是因为自己是老师吧。哈。
(分享一下,我当老师向友人吐苦水时,大家的反应都是,你应该怎样怎样啊。我APPRECIATE.
只是,因为大家都不是老师。)
小斌,I AM SO SORRY,写了真多。
(不是卫护啦,只是因为自己比较可以体谅。)
chengsun
22|Feb|2008 10这样才精彩.
思斌
22|Feb|2008 11harriet,不用道歉。。。欢迎你借题发挥~ 🙂
胡某
24|Feb|2008 12老實說,這位老師的英文也不怎樣,還敢笑人。
.亮
25|Feb|2008 13这就是所谓的50步笑一百步.没有差学生,只有不会树人的烂老师.希望那几个学生可以发奋某天回来笑他的老师.
Leave a reply
Search
Recent Comments
Recent Posts
Categories
Archives
Pages
Meta